“I Gotta” Is All You Got? The Difference Between Obligation and Choice
You can have the house, the car, the job title, and the recognition that comes with years of hard work. You can be at the top of a large organization and have people looking to you for answers.
And you can still be miserable.
I once worked with an executive who had accomplished just about everything he thought he was supposed to accomplish. He had built a successful career, earned the respect of his peers, and reached a position that many people would envy. From the outside, he had a lot going for him.
But he was stressed. He had a lot on his plate, and as we talked, I noticed something about the way he spoke.
He kept starting his sentences with, “I gotta.”
“I gotta get this done.”
“I gotta take care of that.”
“I gotta deal with this person.”
Finally, I stopped him.
“Wait a minute. Aren't you at the top of your company? ‘I gotta’ is all you got?”
Now, I wasn't suggesting that he didn't have responsibilities. He had plenty of them. People depended on him, decisions needed to be made, and his job wasn't going to disappear just because he looked at it differently.
But I wanted him to consider something. Did he really have to do all these things, or had he gotten so accustomed to living a certain way that he no longer recognized the choices he was making?
There is a difference.
You Have Choices, Even When the Choices Are Hard
We started looking at the things he felt obligated to do. Some were genuinely important. Others had become habits. Some were driven by the expectations of other people. Some were connected to the kind of leader he believed he needed to be.
And some were things he chose to do because they aligned with what mattered to him, even when they were difficult.
That last distinction is important.
Choosing something doesn't mean you'll enjoy every part of it. You can choose to take on a difficult responsibility because you value the people who depend on you. You can choose to work through a challenging season because the work matters to you. You can choose to have a hard conversation because honesty is more important than avoiding discomfort.
You may not like all the implications of your choice. You may be tired. You may have to sacrifice some convenience. You may have to accept that you cannot make everyone happy.
But when you recognize that you're choosing something because it aligns with your values, the experience can change.
You're no longer simply a victim of your circumstances. You're making a decision about how you want to live.
That doesn't make the responsibility disappear. It does give you a different relationship with it.
Why We Keep Chasing More
Somewhere along the way, a lot of us start believing that if we work hard enough, accomplish enough, and become successful enough, we'll finally feel like we've made it.
We'll feel secure. We'll feel worthy. We'll finally be able to relax and enjoy the life we've built.
But what happens when you get there and those feelings don't show up the way you expected?
You might assume you haven't done enough yet. So you set another goal, take on another responsibility, or chase the next accomplishment.
Before long, you're working harder to get a feeling that hard work was never guaranteed to give you.
That's worth examining. Not because achievement is bad, but because you deserve to understand what you're asking achievement to do for you.
I think a lot of us operate in “I gotta” mode because we haven't taken the time to get clear about our values.
We know how to set goals. We know how to work hard. We know how to meet expectations and get things done. Many of us have been rewarded for doing those things our entire lives.
But have we stopped to ask why we're doing them?
Are we working late because the work genuinely matters, or because we don't know how to disappoint someone?
Are we chasing another accomplishment because it aligns with what we value, or because we've come to believe that accomplishing more is what makes us worthwhile?
Are we saying yes because we want to, or because we are uncomfortable with what someone might think if we say no?
Those questions aren't always easy to answer.
Sometimes the answers are embarrassing.
Sometimes we discover that the things driving us aren't the things we want driving us.
That's okay. The point isn't to beat yourself up over how you've been living. The point is to become honest enough to do something about it.
Without that honesty, it's easy to spend years building a life around expectations you never consciously chose.
And you can be very successful at building a life that doesn't fit you.
The Executive Didn't Quit His Job
Here's what I find particularly interesting about this executive's story.
He didn't quit his job. He didn't sell his house, buy a cabin in the mountains, or decide that the life he'd built was all wrong.
Instead, we worked together to identify what mattered to him and examine how his responsibilities fit those values.
We began categorizing and prioritizing his work differently, both mentally and emotionally. We looked at what genuinely required his attention, what he could approach differently, and what he had been carrying simply because he believed he had to.
The responsibilities didn't all go away. His job was still demanding. But he began to see his work through a different lens.
He could make choices about how he approached it rather than feeling as though every demand automatically dictated his response.
That's the kind of change I want people to understand is possible.
Sometimes aligning your life with your values requires a dramatic decision. Sometimes it means leaving a job, changing a relationship, or admitting that the path you're on isn't the path you want to continue.
But sometimes the change starts with how you think about the life you already have.
Value alignment doesn't necessarily mean changing everything around you. It means getting honest about what's important to you and making choices that reflect it.
What We Do at Precipice Consulting
This is the central principle behind Precipice Consulting.
We want to help you know yourself well enough to be honest about your values, recognize the choices in front of you, and make decisions that align with what matters most to you.
That sounds simple, but it takes work.
It takes a willingness to look at yourself honestly, including the parts you might not be particularly proud of. It takes examining the assumptions you've carried about success, worth, responsibility, and what it means to be a good leader, spouse, parent, or friend.
And it takes accountability.
Our role isn't to tell you what your values should be. It's to help you identify them, even when the truth is uncomfortable, and hold you accountable to the choices you make once you've identified them.
Because recognizing your values doesn't mean much if you continue to live in a way that contradicts them.
You don't have to abandon the success you've worked so hard to build. But you might need to reconsider what that success is for.
So, the next time you hear yourself say, “I gotta,” stop for a moment.
Maybe you really do need to do the thing in front of you. Or maybe you have a choice you haven't considered.
The question is whether you're making that choice deliberately, with your values in mind, or simply operating on autopilot.
That's worth thinking about.
Three Questions Worth Asking Yourself
Take a little time with these questions. Don't rush to give yourself the answer you think you should give.
Where in my life do I say “I gotta” most often? Is it work, family, money, relationships, or something else? What do I believe would happen if I made a different choice?
What am I trying to protect, prove, or avoid? When I say yes to something I don't want to do, am I acting out of a value I genuinely hold, or am I trying to avoid disappointing someone, losing recognition, or feeling inadequate?
What value do I want my choices to reflect? If someone looked at how I spend my time, energy, and attention, what would they conclude matters most to me? Would that match what I say matters most?
An Exercise: Replace “I Gotta” With “I Choose”
For the next three days, pay attention to how often you say or think, “I gotta.”
Each time you catch yourself, write down the task or responsibility.
Then work through these three steps:
1. Identify the choice.
Rewrite “I gotta do this” as “I choose to do this because…” Complete the sentence honestly. If you can't identify a reason beyond “because I have to,” spend a little time examining that belief.
2. Identify the value.
Ask yourself which value, if any, this choice serves. Is it responsibility, family, honesty, excellence, financial security, service, or something else? There isn't a right answer. You're trying to understand your own motivations.
3. Decide whether the choice still fits.
Ask yourself whether this responsibility deserves the time and energy you're giving it. Could you approach it differently, set a boundary, delegate it, or decide that it no longer belongs on your plate?
You don't have to change every decision. Sometimes you'll conclude that the responsibility is important and that you are willing to accept its costs. That's a choice, too.
At the end of the three days, look back at what you wrote.
Where were your choices aligned with your values? Where were you operating out of habit, fear, or someone else's expectations? What surprised you?
Don't use the exercise to judge yourself. Use it to get to know yourself.
Because the goal isn't to eliminate every “I gotta” from your life.
The goal is to know why you're doing what you're doing, and to make sure the life you're building is one you actually want to live.
Comments